Join today to claim your daily loot

15 Urban Video Game Legends We All Believed Were True

1-15

Ignacio Weil

Gaming - September 3rd 2026, 11:00 GMT+2

Herobrine Minecraft 2011 — 15. Herobrine – Minecraft (2011)

Herobrine never appeared in an official version of *Minecraft*, but low render distances and lonely worlds made him remarkably easy to imagine. The white-eyed Steve lookalike originated in a fabricated 2010 story before staged livestream footage helped the rumor explode. Claims that he was the ghost of Notch’s dead brother were also invented, though Mojang mischievously kept the legend alive by repeatedly writing “Removed Herobrine” in update notes. | © Mojang Studios

Cropped Ben Drowned The Legend of Zelda Majoras Mask 2000 — 14. Ben Drowned – The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask (2000)

A blank Nintendo 64 cartridge marked “Majora,” an abandoned save file named BEN and an Elegy of Emptiness statue that refused to stop following the player—this one had excellent ingredients. Alexander D. Hall, writing as Jadusable, created BEN Drowned as a multimedia horror story in 2010, combining edited gameplay videos, forum posts and audience participation. It was an ARG rather than a genuine haunted cartridge, but plenty of viewers slept less comfortably before learning that distinction. | © Nintendo

Bigfoot Grand Theft Auto San Andreas 2004 — 13. Bigfoot / Sasquatch – Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas (2004)

The forests surrounding Mount Chiliad were foggy, unusually quiet and large enough to hide one very pixelated ape. Players began circulating alleged Bigfoot sightings soon after *Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas* arrived, supported by blurry screenshots that conveniently revealed nothing. Rockstar developers denied that Sasquatch existed in the original game, yet the hunt continued for years through mods and manipulated videos. Rockstar eventually rewarded the obsession by introducing genuine Bigfoot encounters elsewhere in the series. | © Rockstar Games

GNR building plaza Fallout 3 2008 — 12. The Numbers Station – Fallout 3 (2008)

According to this unsettling rumor, killing Three Dog and destroying Raven Rock could transform Galaxy News Radio into a numbers station broadcasting coded predictions of real-world disasters. Supposed messages were connected to events including the Deepwater Horizon oil spill and Gary Coleman’s death, giving *Fallout 3* the inconvenient ability to see beyond its own release date. Bethesda denied placing such broadcasts in the game, and no verifiable recording or game data ever surfaced. It was an elaborate creepypasta wearing a convincing Pip-Boy costume. | © Bethesda Softworks

Cropped Madden NFL 1999 — 11. The Madden Curse – Madden NFL series (1999)

Appearing on a *Madden NFL* cover should have been a victory lap, yet fans began treating it like an appointment with an orthopedic surgeon. Garrison Hearst suffered a serious ankle injury after featuring on the international cover of *Madden NFL 99*, while later stars endured injuries, poor seasons or abrupt career turns. The curse ignores healthy cover athletes and the naturally brutal odds of professional football, but every fresh setback renews it. Statistical reasoning never stood much chance against several badly timed torn ligaments. | © EA Sports

Shadowplay Luigis Mansion 2001 — 10. Luigi’s Hanging Shadow - Luigi’s Mansion (2001)

During the blackout sequence in *Luigi’s Mansion*, a flash of lightning in the Telephone Room projects Luigi’s shadow high onto the wall. Its strange position and stretched neck led players to see the silhouette of Luigi hanging from the ceiling, supposedly revealing that the entire adventure occurred after his death. The sinister image is really a lighting and camera quirk, not Nintendo quietly inserting a suicide narrative into Mario’s ghost-hunting spinoff. The effect was removed from the Nintendo 3DS remake. | © Nintendo

Cropped Aerith death Final Fantasy VII 1997 — 9. You Can Save Aerith – Final Fantasy VII (1997)

Aerith’s death was so difficult to accept that players turned grief into unpaid detective work. Rumored revival methods involved collecting every 1/35 Soldier, finding hidden materia, raising a special Chocobo or completing suspiciously specific tasks at the church. None could restore her in the original story, because her permanent absence was fundamental to what *Final Fantasy VII* wanted to say about death. Hacks and later glitches can keep her in the party, but the game has no legitimate resurrection quest waiting to be discovered. | © Square Enix

L Is Real 2401 Super Mario 64 1996 — 8. L Is Real 2401 – Super Mario 64 (1996)

The blurry inscription beneath the courtyard statue appeared to read “L Is Real 2401,” and that was enough to launch a thousand imaginary Luigi unlock methods. Players collected coins, circled the fountain and completed increasingly ridiculous challenges, but Mario’s brother was never playable in the finished game. The myth received a strange consolation prize decades later when leaked development files revealed an unused Luigi model from a discarded multiplayer concept. Luigi was real, technically—he simply wasn’t hiding beneath the statue. | © Nintendo

Mew Under the Truck Pokémon Red and Blue 1996 — 7. Mew Under the Truck – Pokémon Red and Blue (1996)

A lonely truck near the S.S. Anne became the center of Pokémon’s greatest playground conspiracy. If players prevented the ship from leaving, returned later with Surf and used Strength on the vehicle, Mew would supposedly emerge from underneath it. The truck is real and awkwardly difficult to reach, which gave the story just enough credibility to survive countless failed attempts. Mew is genuinely hidden within the game’s code—and can be encountered through an unrelated glitch—but it was never waiting beneath that pickup. | © Nintendo

Secret Warrior Cows Diablo — 6. The Secret Cow Level – Diablo (1997)

Clicking repeatedly on the cows in Tristram produced several increasingly irritated responses, so players naturally concluded that the animals guarded an entire hidden dungeon. No Secret Cow Level exists in the original *Diablo*, regardless of how many times its livestock is bothered. Blizzard enjoyed the rumor enough to reference it with the *StarCraft* cheat “There is no cow level,” then made the joke real in *Diablo II*. There, players could finally battle armies of halberd-wielding cattle and their appropriately titled Cow King. | © Blizzard Entertainment

Lara Croft Nude Code Tomb Raider 1996 — 5. Lara Croft Nude Code – Tomb Raider (1996)

Playground sources and gaming magazines confidently promised that one elaborate button combination would remove Lara Croft’s famously angular outfit. The exact instructions changed with every retelling, which should have been suspicious, but players kept entering codes as though archaeology depended on it. Core Design never included an official nude mode in *Tomb Raider*, although unofficial PC patches eventually produced the result rumor hunters wanted. The legendary cheat was fantasy; the internet’s determination to manufacture it was painfully real. | © Core Design

Cropped Lavender Town Pokémon Red Green 1996 — 4. Lavender Town Syndrome - Pokémon Red and Green (1996)

Lavender Town already contained a Pokémon cemetery and one of the eeriest themes a Game Boy speaker could produce; the internet supplied the dead children. The Lavender Town Syndrome story claimed that high frequencies in the original Japanese music caused headaches, illness and a wave of suicides among young players. No contemporary reports support any such event, and the legend emerged as creepypasta years later. Its disturbing plausibility borrowed heavily from Pokémon’s real seizure controversy, despite the two stories having no actual connection. | © Nintendo

Shen Long Street Fighter II 1991 — 3. Sheng Long Is in the Game – Street Fighter II (1991)

Ryu’s poorly translated victory line declared, “You must defeat Sheng Long to stand a chance,” convincing players that a secret martial-arts master existed somewhere in *Street Fighter II*. *Electronic Gaming Monthly* exploited the confusion with an April Fools’ guide demanding a nearly impossible sequence of flawless rounds and draws. Other publications repeated the instructions seriously, sending players back to the arcade with pockets full of quarters. Sheng Long was fictional, although Capcom eventually acknowledged the joke with a character bearing the name in *Street Fighter 6*. | © Capcom

Cropped Ermac Mortal Kombat 1992 — 2. Ermac Is a Playable Character – Mortal Kombat (1992)

Ermac began not as a ninja but as bookkeeping. The original *Mortal Kombat* contained an audit label reading “ERMACS,” short for “error macros,” positioned close enough to Reptile’s statistics to suggest another hidden opponent. A submitted photograph of a supposedly red-colored ninja pushed the rumor further, despite no playable Ermac existing in the game. Midway eventually surrendered to its own audience and transformed the accidental name into a real fighter for *Ultimate Mortal Kombat 3*. The fans were wrong until the developers made them right. | © Midway Games

Cropped Polybius 1981 — 1. The Phantom Arcade Cabinet – Polybius (1981)

The perfect video game urban legend concerns a cabinet nobody can prove existed. *Polybius* supposedly appeared in Portland arcades, delivering abstract visuals so addictive that players suffered hallucinations, seizures and memory loss while mysterious men collected data from the machines. No contemporary advertisement, ROM, cabinet or record of its alleged developer has ever been found; known references appeared years later online. Real FBI visits to Portland arcades and reports of players becoming ill may have fed the mythology, but the government mind-control game remains wonderfully imaginary. | © Wikipedia

1-15

Before every rumor could be disproved with a quick Google search, video game secrets spread through playground whispers, suspicious screenshots and that one friend whose uncle supposedly worked at Nintendo. Hidden characters, haunted cartridges and impossible unlock codes felt entirely plausible when nobody had the evidence to say otherwise. Some of these gaming urban legends were clever hoaxes; others grew from glitches, mistranslations or pure wishful thinking. Either way, we desperately wanted them to be true—and a few still refuse to die.

Facebook X Reddit WhatsApp Copy URL

Before every rumor could be disproved with a quick Google search, video game secrets spread through playground whispers, suspicious screenshots and that one friend whose uncle supposedly worked at Nintendo. Hidden characters, haunted cartridges and impossible unlock codes felt entirely plausible when nobody had the evidence to say otherwise. Some of these gaming urban legends were clever hoaxes; others grew from glitches, mistranslations or pure wishful thinking. Either way, we desperately wanted them to be true—and a few still refuse to die.