Florida Man Arrested After Mailing Peanut Butter-Covered Card to Woman With Deadly Allergy

A man in Florida has been taken into custody after potentially putting a woman's life at risk.

Florida Man Arrested For Sending Peanut Butter Card to Woman With Peanuty Allergy
Cancellare now faces two charges related to the incident. | © Plantation Police Department

A Florida man has been arrested after allegedly mailing a greeting card smeared with peanut butter to a woman with a severe peanut allergy.

Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., a 68-year-old man, was arrested on November 13 and charged with aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence exposing another person to harm, according to the Plantation Police Department.

The incident reportedly happened on August 14, 2025, when the unidentified woman returned home from work and discovered a blue envelope in her driveway. After opening it, she reportedly found a greeting card "smeared with peanut butter" across the inside.

The woman then dropped the envelope and rushed inside to wash her hands. However, she later developed hives on both arms and experienced tingling sensations that lasted approximately six hours, according to investigators.

Cancellare Knew Woman Had Deadly Peanut Allergy

Police said Cancellare was well aware of the woman's potentially life-threatening allergy, as the two had known each other for more than 20 years. They had regularly spent time together socially, and Cancellare had reportedly witnessed her taking precautions to avoid accidental contact with peanuts.

Investigators eventually worked with the U.S. Postal Service to trace the envelope. They discovered that two Forever stamps used on the mailing had been purchased, a day before the incident, at Davie Post Office on South University Drive using a Visa card belonging to Cancellare.

The post office also captured a photograph of the person purchasing the stamps. When shown the image, the victim immediately identified Cancellare, while several other acquaintances also reportedly recognized him.

Police further alleged that he attempted to conceal his identity by using a fictitious name and return address on the envelope.

Police Uncover Suspect's Motivations

According to investigators, the alleged attack may have been connected to Cancellare's contentious divorce from his wife, who was the victim's longtime best friend.

Authorities said Cancellare largely blamed the woman for the breakdown of the marriage and had allegedly made remarks about wanting to harm people connected to the situation.

Following an investigation that continued into 2026, officers arrested Cancellare at his home. He now faces charges of aggravated battery and culpable negligence.

Ivan Shahran

Gamer, writer and night owl. Big nerd about indie movies and music. I write about mobile gaming and eSports but also manage the socials....