An Oscar on the poster can cover a remarkable amount of nonsense. From Suicide Squad’s muddled supervillain mission to Pearl Harbor’s exhausting love triangle, these award-winning movies combine celebrated craftsmanship with some deeply questionable storytelling. There are clumsy biopics, hollow prestige dramas, and blockbusters that mistake expensive noise for excitement. The statuettes are real; the case for sitting through these films is considerably shakier. Even the most glamorous trophy cabinet deserves the occasional second opinion.
