Some villains don’t get defeated – they get recast in your head. One scene they’re the problem, the next they’re the only one being honest, brave, or weirdly principled, and you’re caught rooting for them before you’ve had time to negotiate with yourself.
Redemption arcs can be cheap, but the good ones sting a little: guilt, pride, a debt they didn’t expect to owe. These movies know exactly when to pull the rug and when to let the former “bad guy” earn the turn.