The Best Cristin Milioti Roles in Movies and TV Ranked

About This Gallery:

For this list, we’re ranking Cristin Milioti’s most memorable roles in movies and TV. The focus is on her performances – how she inhabits each character and what makes her stand out – rather than the overall quality of the project. Some roles might come from films or shows that weren’t widely acclaimed, but Milioti’s work in them is worth noting, making this a true look at her career highlights. | © Warner Bros. Television

10. Hazel Green - Made For Love (2021-2022)

Getting trapped in a tech billionaire’s dystopian love experiment sounds like the worst dating app nightmare, but Cristin Milioti’s Hazel Green turns it into sharp, dark comedy gold. Hazel is wry, flawed, and endlessly relatable as she literally runs away from a marriage where her husband has implanted a tracking chip in her brain. Milioti balances desperation with deadpan wit, making Hazel one of the most human sci-fi heroines in recent TV. The series might be satirical, but her performance grounds it with surprising warmth and grit, proving once again that Milioti can carry a story that’s both hilarious and heartbreaking. It’s equal parts tragic, absurd, and – dare we say – uncomfortably plausible. | © HBO Max

9. Maggie Mitchell - Modern Love (2019-2021)

In the anthology series that turns New York Times essays into miniature emotional rollercoasters, Cristin Milioti’s Maggie Mitchell shows up with all the quirks and contradictions of modern dating. Her episode dives headfirst into messy romance, vulnerability, and the little victories that come with trying to navigate connections in a world that often feels allergic to sincerity. Milioti brings a glow of authenticity here, the kind that makes you think: “Oh, I’ve definitely had that awkward conversation.” What could’ve been just another romantic dramedy segment becomes something tender and resonant thanks to her ability to shift between laughter and heartbreak in a heartbeat. It’s like she knows how to play the exact chord that makes you wince and smile at the same time. | © Amazon Studios

8. Emma - The Resort (2022)

Mysteries get extra addictive when Cristin Milioti is involved, and in The Resort, her character Emma transforms what could have been a straightforward whodunnit into something so much more. On vacation with her husband, Emma stumbles into a decades-old disappearance that quickly spirals into a mix of existential dread and dark comedy. Milioti thrives in this genre-bending chaos, leaning into Emma’s restless spirit and simmering dissatisfaction with her life. It’s a performance that feels adventurous and raw, reminding viewers that a midlife crisis can be just as gripping as a murder mystery. She makes you laugh, then immediately question your own choices, which is a pretty powerful party trick. | © Peacock

7. Nanette Cole - Black Mirror (2011-Present)

Every once in a while, Black Mirror gifts us a performance that completely takes over the cultural conversation, and Cristin Milioti’s Nanette Cole in “USS Callister” is one of those rare gems. She starts off as a seemingly secondary character in a retro-futuristic nightmare, only to become the story’s real captain – figuratively and literally. Watching Milioti flip from charming newbie to sharp, fearless leader is exhilarating, especially in an episode that skewers toxic fanboy culture with laser precision. Her Nanette is witty, brave, and proof that you should never underestimate the new recruit on the spaceship. It’s one of those episodes that makes you cheer, laugh, and squirm in equal measure – and Milioti nails every beat. | © Netflix

6. Catherine Sacrimoni - The Sopranos (1999-2007)

Before her leading-lady era, Cristin Milioti popped up in one of TV’s most legendary dramas as Catherine Sacrimoni. The role may not be as flashy as others on this list, but it’s a fascinating time capsule of her early career. Catherine is the daughter of mobster Johnny Sack, and her storyline dips into the family drama with the kind of understated presence that feels lived-in and real. Even in limited screen time, Milioti manages to stand out in a series packed with powerhouse performances. Looking back now, it’s fun to see the seeds of her future brilliance – proof that even small roles can showcase an actor’s spark if they’ve got the right mix of subtlety and presence. | © HBO

5. Betsy Solverson - Fargo (2014-Present)

In a show famous for its eccentric criminals and bleak humor, Cristin Milioti’s Betsy Solverson brings something startlingly gentle yet unshakably strong. Betsy is the quiet heart of season two, a character fighting both a spreading criminal empire and her own failing health with unflinching dignity. Milioti doesn’t need explosive monologues or over-the-top drama; she makes Betsy unforgettable through stillness, grace, and a fierce devotion to her family. Watching her navigate the chaos of small-town Midwest crime with such calm resilience is almost eerie in its power. It’s the kind of performance that makes you pause, realizing that sometimes the quietest characters leave the loudest impact. | © FX

4. Sarah Wilder - Palm Springs (2020)

Who knew existential dread could be so funny? Cristin Milioti’s Sarah Wilder finds herself trapped in a time loop alongside Andy Samberg, and instead of just going for Groundhog Day-style gags, she gives the story emotional weight. Sarah is messy, conflicted, and trying to outrun mistakes, which makes her infinitely more relatable than your average rom-com heroine. Milioti spins sci-fi absurdity into something disarmingly heartfelt, building chemistry that feels alive and unpredictable. She manages to turn a cosmic joke into a story about second chances, and the result is a role that feels tailor-made for her mix of humor and gravitas. It’s easily one of her most celebrated performances, and for good reason – you don’t forget Sarah once you’ve been stuck in her loop. | © Neon

Cropped Tracy Mc Connell The Mother How I Met Your Mother

3. Tracy McConnell/The Mother - How I Met Your Mother (2005-2014)

For years, fans speculated about “The Mother,” and when Cristin Milioti finally appeared as Tracy McConnell, she proved worth the wait. Tracy radiated charm, humor, and warmth from her very first moments on screen, instantly making audiences root for her connection with Ted. Even though she entered the story late, Milioti infused the character with so much life that she felt like she’d always been part of the gang. The bittersweet ending of the series may have divided fans, but nearly everyone agreed that Milioti made the elusive Mother unforgettable. She wasn’t just a plot twist – she was a living, breathing character who elevated the entire final season. | © 20th Century Fox Television

Cropped Teresa Petrillo The Wolf Of Wall Street

2. Teresa Petrillo - The Wolf Of Wall Street (2013)

In a movie bursting with outrageous performances, Cristin Milioti made a lasting impression as Teresa Petrillo, Jordan Belfort’s first wife. While the role could have easily faded into the background of financial debauchery, she imbued Teresa with a sharp intelligence and palpable heartbreak that gave early scenes a real emotional core. Watching her character navigate the fallout of Jordan’s escalating corruption, you get a glimpse of the cost behind all the greed and chaos. Milioti’s grounded portrayal acts as a necessary counterbalance to DiCaprio’s manic energy, reminding viewers that real lives get crushed under the glittering façade of excess. It’s a smaller role, but one that showcases her ability to stand toe-to-toe with Hollywood heavyweights. | © Paramount Pictures

1. Sofia Falcone - The Penguin (2024)

Cristin Milioti stepping into Gotham as Sofia Falcone feels like a casting dream we didn’t know we needed. The daughter of Carmine Falcone, Sofia is a complex figure: dangerous, calculating, and as formidable as any villain stalking the city. With Milioti’s knack for layering vulnerability beneath strength, Sofia becomes more than just another crime boss heir – she’s a potential game-changer in the Batman universe. There’s a delicious unpredictability in how she might clash with Colin Farrell’s Penguin, which makes her presence one of the show’s biggest wild cards. If her past roles are any indication, Milioti will twist expectations in the best way possible, giving Gotham a new kind of queenpin to fear and admire. | © Warner Bros. Television